Table of Contents
The very name, Islamorada conjures a sense of mystique and exotic allure. Known as the “Village of Islands,” it stretches across 20 miles and encompasses six of the Florida Keys: Plantation, Windley, Upper Matecumbe, Lower Matecumbe, Tea Table, and Lignumvitae. But, to its residents, Islamorada is more than just a place to live – it’s a way of life.
Beyond its tranquil setting, natural splendor, and renowned fishing spots, Islamorada thrives on its close-knit communities. Its locals are united not only by their love of the water but also by their passion for art. Whether through creation or appreciation, art plays a central role in their lives.
Surrounded by the islands’ breathtaking nature, creativity flourishes, making it a perfect home for art galleries in Islamorada, Florida, where the fusion of culture and environment flourishes.
ISLAMORADA, A DYNAMIC CULTURAL DESTINATION
The Florida Keys are famous for their vacation appeal – pleasant climate, pristine beaches, luxurious resorts, and abundant shopping options that draw countless visitors to these islands. However, the Keys also have a strong affinity for the arts.
Thriving arts scene
Islamorada, Florida boasts an active arts scene, featuring galleries, festivals, and events that celebrate local culture and creativity. In buying any of the lovely homes for sale here, you get to discover first-hand the color and vibrancy of this village’s wonderful facet.
Rich history
Historical sites and museums highlight the area’s cultural depth, offering insight into its maritime heritage and contributions to underwater exploration.
Community ties through art
Art unites Islamorada’s community, fostering connection and identity as the island’s beauty inspires artists and patrons.
Lively performance art scene
Regular performances of live music, theater, and dance enhance the area’s cultural offerings and the islands’ dynamism.
ART’S IMPACT ON ISLAMORADA, FLORIDA’S REAL ESTATE AND COMMUNITY
The local art scene plays a key role in enriching community life, fostering creativity, and boosting property appeal.
Making properties stand out
Art enriches the local lifestyle, making homes more attractive and unique in the competitive real estate market.
Increased property values
Properties in artistically vibrant areas often experience increased value because of their unique offerings. The presence of art galleries in Islamorada, Florida attracts prospective home buyers who value cultural experiences.
Fostering community identity
Art fosters a sense of belonging among residents. Community art projects and local galleries contribute to a shared cultural identity, strengthening social bonds.
Unique living experience
Art elevates the living experience in Islamorada by integrating creativity into everyday life. The presence of art crafts a stimulating environment and lifestyle that complements the idyllic island living.
MUST-VISIT ART GALLERIES IN AND AROUND ISLAMORADA, FLORIDA
Islamorada is home to several art galleries, showcasing works from local and international artists. These galleries are community hubs where visitors experience the creative spirit that defines the islands.
Lobster Trap Art
82200 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
This unique gallery was started in 2003 by Nadine and Glenn Lahti, artists who began painting over two decades ago. The gallery’s name is inspired by the lobster traps the couple crafts by hand. They also create original and colorful tropical paintings which they sell globally online.
Artworks: Aside from being a gallery, Lobster Trap doubles as a gift shop, offering marine-inspired art that also function as décor. Other best-selling items include underwater art prints, ceramic tile murals, lobster trap photo frames, and other custom products. Featured nautical artworks are made by Nadine and Glenn, as well as other artists in the area.
Islamorada Art Gallery by Pasta
81599 Old Highway, Islamorada
Roberto “Pasta” Pantaleo, an Italian-American artist from Brooklyn, discovered his passion for custom airbrushing in the 1970s. His talent gained fame in South Florida’s vibrant scene. In 2001, Pasta’s painting for Bluewater Movements’ fishing tournament, “Everybody is Gonna Be There,” boosted his reputation, leading to a surge in interest in his marine art.
Artworks: Pasta is a prolific artist, known for his diverse range of paintings featuring turtles, mangroves, birds, boats, and pop art. He also creates installations and sculptures that serve as striking statement pieces and conversation starters when displayed at home.
The Rum Brush
77522 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Rum Brush artist and owner Keith Ousley specializes in eye-catching, large-scale mixed-media paintings and murals centered on marine life and conservation. His work, including the notable “Legend of Scarface” tarpon wall at Robbie’s Marina, graces Florida Keys businesses such as Florida Keys Brewing Co. and various roadside spots in the Stock Island Art District and Key Largo.
Artworks: Immerse yourself in Ousley’s colorful and edgy paintings with tropical fish, pelicans, sea turtles, and manatees as usual subjects. The shop also offers whimsical items like hand-painted roller skates and “Mangrove Berry” bracelets, made from braided hemp and beads.
Gyotaku by Lisa Lee
81641 Old Highway, Islamorada
Lisa Lee, a talented artist from Fort Lauderdale, now lives and operates her gallery in the Florida Keys, where she specializes in Gyotaku – a traditional Japanese fish printing technique. After studying in prestigious art schools, including Edinburgh College of Art and under Master Matsunaga in Japan, Lisa’s work merges her love for the ocean with diverse cultural influences. Her prints and abstract pieces capture the ocean’s beauty and intricacies.
Artworks: The shop sells Lee’s originals and reproductions, as well as clutch purses, pillows, glassware, delicate bowls, candles, and gift cards that feature the artists’ unique work.
Seaside Glassworks
81902 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Founded by husband-and-wife duo Edward and Stephanie Martin, this art studio and charming shop draws inspiration from Florida Keys’ beautiful surroundings. Stephanie is a warm glass artist renowned for her luminous glass fish jewelry and sea life art. Specializing in dichroic glass, she captures the ocean’s natural glow. She works alongside her husband in the studio.
Artworks: Aside from colorful jewelry, the shop also offers fine art, customized light features, and pet portraits. The shop also holds introduction to jewelry-making sessions on select weekdays.
Our Place in Paradise
8871 Overseas Highway, Tavernier
About 15 minutes from Islamorada is this art gallery that offers original paintings, pottery, and glass. Meanwhile, workshops and classes cater to those eager to learn new skills or improve their existing talents. The gallery showcases diverse, high-quality artists and recently hosted the Paradise Paint Out, featuring 25 artists from the U.S. and England. Supported by a non-profit organization, Our Place in Paradise promotes art education and community support.
Artworks: Dive into masterpieces from different art forms, such as photography, ceramics, and fine art from local artists.
Rain Barrel Village
86700 Overseas Highway, Tavernier
Since 1978, this venue has been dedicated to supporting local art as a key element of life in the Florida Keys. It has had the privilege of collaborating with numerous resident artists and craftsmen, resulting in galleries that feature the work of over 500 artists. A highlight is Betsy the Lobster, a striking 30-foot-tall sculpture of a spiny lobster at the entrance. Guests may also savor delectable food and drinks at the on-site eateries while enjoying the peaceful gardens and delightful shops.
Artworks: Here, you’ll find an array of handmade and semi-precious jewelry, home décor, paintings, ceramics, pottery, watercolor prints, photographs, and so much more.
Jessica Ann Art Gallery
151 Morada Way Unit 1, Islamorada
Jessica, a marine life artist from the area, creates art to connect people with their marine experiences and promote ocean conservation. Her vibrant, self-taught work features bold colors and clean lines, inspired by the vivid sea life and tropical flora. Using fluid and heavy-body acrylics and inks, her pieces offer unique texture and movement, reflecting her passion for the ocean.
Artworks: Choose from Jessica’s paintings of tropical blooms, animals, and landscapes. Her creations are also available as apparel prints, home décor, and accessories, allowing customers to bring a touch of the ocean into their daily lives.
Amy’s Creations of the Florida Keys
86700 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Amy JoAn, a versatile professional multimedium artist based in the Florida Keys, specializes in custom murals, furniture restorations, and decorative art. Her shop features personalized signs made from reclaimed wood and industrial paints, ensuring longevity. Whether it’s restoring furniture or creating custom artwork, Amy transforms any surface into a masterpiece.
Artworks: Known for her expertise in working with wood, metal, and fiberglass, Amy offers hand-sculpted and hand-painted pieces that are not only unique but also durable enough to withstand outdoor elements.
Finders Keepers Coconut Arts Studio
86701 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Art can be fun and enjoyed by everyone – this is the unofficial motto of this studio, where guests may purchase masterpieces from local artists or create their own with playful, hands-on projects. This art group also hosts painting parties for all ages, offering a variety of materials like canvas, wood, and ornaments. Additional activities include sand art and the opportunity to build a personalized plushie toy, similar to a Build-a-Bear experience. Mobile creative parties are available, bringing entertainment like face painting, temporary tattoos, juggling stations, and more.
Artworks: A unique feature is their hand-painted coconuts, left in random places for people to find and keep, creating a delightful treasure hunt.
Jellyfish Daydreams
81888 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Though specializing in custom tattoos, the studio also has an art gallery showcasing local artwork and handcrafted jewelry. It also hosts art and jewelry-making classes and private sessions for friends or family gatherings. Jellyfish Daydreams proudly supports local environmental organizations. With a strong focus on marine conservation, 10% of all the studio’s proceeds are donated to coral restoration efforts in the Florida Keys.
Artworks: Aside from tattoos, the studio also welcomes art commissions. For a truly personalized experience, clients may video-chat directly with one of the studio’s artists to create their perfect and unique jellyfish-themed piece.
Sherri Griffin Photography and Airplant Jellyfish
80925 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Originally from Upstate New York, Griffin moved to the Florida Keys in 2011 and quickly became passionate about photography, capturing stunning sunrises and sunsets. After Hurricane Irma in 2017, she discovered a new love for air plants, transforming sea urchins into beautiful “jellyfish” with blooming air plants. This led to her business venture, which offers scenic photography of the area in the form of calendars, prints, and gifts. She also started selling her air plants displayed in terrariums, macrame, and driftwood art.
Artworks: Griffin’s best-selling pieces are her sunset photographs and unique air plant designs.
The Hale Gallery
81888 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
Owned by oil painter Taylor Hale and his wife, Kelly, The Hale is a contemporary fine art gallery displaying curated, rotating exhibitions that feature local, regional, and national artists. Committed to fostering creativity and community, the gallery assists both new and seasoned collectors in finding pieces that will enrich their lives. Aside from exhibitions and events, the gallery also occasionally hosts yoga classes, blending art with wellness for a truly creative environment.
Artworks: Featured artists include painters Andrea Munchmeyer, John David Hawver, Pasta Pantaleo, and more.
Key Largo Art Gallery
103200 Overseas Highway #10, Key Largo
About 30 minutes away from Islamorada is this gallery, owned by Cuban-American artist Carmen Sotolongo-Kelley. It showcases a diverse array of pieces from 30 award-winning local artists. Kelley, known for her vibrant and bold art reflecting her life and background, has been a significant figure in the Upper Keys’ art and education scenes. With a teaching career spanning over 30 years at Coral Shores High School and the University of South Florida, Kelley’s gallery is a celebration of eclectic and nostalgic creativity.
Artworks: The gallery displays oil paintings, acrylics, watercolors, woodwork, jewelry, faux paintings, furniture, and painted wine glasses, along with commission work.
Kona Kai Resort, Gallery, and Botanic Garden
97802 Overseas Highway, Key Largo
Nestled on two serene bayside acres in Key Largo is Kona Kai, which offers an intimate and peaceful retreat. Guest rooms in this resort are adorned with local art, tropical textiles, and abundant natural light. Guests may enjoy a range of outdoor activities, including kayaking, tennis, and exploring the onsite botanical gardens. Kona Kai also features a dedicated gallery space, welcoming all guests and art enthusiasts to experience its exhibits and gallery nights.
Artworks: The art gallery highlights works by talented artists inspired by tropical life and the Florida Keys.
MUST-SEE MUSEUMS
Islamorada’s storied past and rich culture meld in museums that showcase its maritime heritage, local art, and the unique history of Florida Keys.
History of Diving Museum
82990 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
For over four decades, Drs. Joe and Sally Bauer amassed one of the world’s largest collections of diving helmets, air pumps, and other gear, along with memorabilia, photos, films, and prints. Their passion for diving history is reflected in the museum’s collection, which now highlights contributions from over 30 countries that explain the evolution of diving technology.
Artworks: While the museum focuses on underwater exploration’s evolution, centered on diving equipment and educational displays, there are some artistic elements. These include interpretive exhibitions, artistic representations of underwater scenes, and temporary exhibits featuring marine-themed artwork.
Florida Keys History and Discovery Center
82100 Overseas Highway, Islamorada
See how Islamorada’s history and natural beauty inspire its art scene in this center, established by the Florida Keys History and Discovery Foundation. Permanent exhibits highlight Native American history, pirates, Spanish treasure fleets, and the development of the Upper Keys, including Henry Flagler’s Over-Sea Railway and the 1935 Labor Day Hurricane. The Coral Reef Exploration exhibit, in partnership with Mote Marine Laboratory, features aquariums showcasing the coral reef ecosystem. Recent additions include a 16th-century cannon and an 18th-century anchor. The second floor houses rotating exhibits, The Jerry Wilkinson Research Library, and a 35-seat theater with documentaries on local history.
MUST-ATTEND ART EVENTS
Art events bring together artists and visitors for celebrations of creativity, culture, and craftsmanship, making Islamorada a true cultural gem.
Morada Way Art Walk
151 Morada Way, Islamorada
Every third Thursday of the month, the Morada Way Arts and Cultural District holds its Art Walk. This regular gathering brings together Keys-based fine artists, locals, visitors, and vendors to celebrate art and culture in the picturesque area. Since its inception in 2011, the event has provided a platform for emerging artists, performers, chefs, and local businesses to present their offerings and talents within a six-block stretch between Mile Markers 81 and 82. The Art Walk also coincides with gallery openings and live music, offering guests delicious food and drinks amid a festive atmosphere.
Island Fest
Founders Park, Mile Marker 87
This annual event usually held in April features a juried art show, live music, food, and many more. This Islamorada Chamber of Commerce fundraiser also welcomes artists who want to display their paintings, sculptures, jewelry, and driftwood carvings. In the recently concluded festival, a cooking competition was held, showcasing top local restaurants. Meanwhile, car enthusiasts enjoyed the road vintage cruisers car exhibit, which featured All-American classic vehicles. This family-friendly event also encouraged children to paint a life-sized dolphin, build sandcastles, and participate in contests like hula-hoop and a homemade boat race.
HOME IS WHERE THE ART IS IN ISLAMORADA, FLORIDA
Islamorada’s lively arts scene and stunning natural beauty make it a great spot to call home. With local galleries, museums, and fun festivals, the area offers an exciting lifestyle that adds extra charm and value to owning a home here.
As your dedicated Realtor in Islamorada, Florida, I – Alina Davis – offer personal service with professional results. Named Realtor of the Year and a Top Producer since 2011, I’m here to help you find your ideal home in this art-inspired and beautiful area. Contact me today at 305.393.0541 or via email.